Nehru and Kashmir: After SC’s Article 370 Order, BJP Attempts to Distort History Again

After the Supreme Court supported the dilution of Article 370, the RSS ideologues are commemorating it as a ratification of the Union federal government’s choice while leaders of celebrations based in Jammu and Kashmir are aghast with the choice. Hours before the leading court pronounced the order, Amit Shah seized the day to damn Jawaharlal Nehru yet once again. Utilizing selective and distorted history, the RSS-BJP has actually been promoting the story that had Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel managed the Kashmir problem, the issue would have been resolved then and there. Contributing to that, Shah mentioned that Nehru’s choice to state a ceasefire with Pakistan was a Himalayan oversight which giving unique status to J&K– which he painted as Nehru’s choice alone– was an error which resulted in a series of issues. These allegations are far from the truth of the occasions that unfolded. The effort to reveal Nehru and Patel as having varying viewpoints on Kashmir is an invention of creativity which abuses the realities of history to the extreme. It was due to the actions of Nehru (and Sheikh Abdullah) that Kashmir acceded to India. Maharaja Hari Singh had actually declined to combine with India, a choice that was supported by the Praja Parishad. Sardar Patel, who was handling the combination of handsome states, had enough on his plate. Rajmohan Gandhi in his book Patel a Life mentions that what Patel wanted about Kashmir was to strike a deal: to have Hyderabad for India and to let Pakistan have Kashmir. Rajmohan Gandhi mentions a speech Patel provided at the Bahauddin College in Junagadh following the latter’s merger with India, when he stated, “We would accept Kashmir if they accepted Hyderabad.” The treaty of accession with India was signed by Maharaja Hari Singh after the marauding tribal militias introduced by the Pakistan army were close to Srinagar. He approached India, whose leaders sent out the army on the condition that Kashmir accede to India. Check out The Backstory of Article 370: A True Copy of J&K’s Instrument of Accession When Hari Singh cultivated imagine an Independent Kashmir and Patel was content with ensuring that Hyderabad combines with India, it was Sheikh Abdullah who promoted that the area sign up with the Indian Union. His factor to consider was not religious beliefs however the suitables of secularism and socialism. He liked land reforms, which he viewed as an impossibility in Pakistan, where the primary management had a feudal state of mind. With numerous Indian leaders talking socialism, he felt it was possible here. His belief in a nonreligious India was based upon Gandhi and Nehru’s messages. Shah and other RSS ideologues state that Nehru’s choice to accept a ceasefire was malfunctioning and was under the pressure of British leaders, to whose viewpoint Nehru gave in. This once again is negated by the truths of history. At the time, Lord Mountbatten was the guv general of India. He recommended a cease-fire and took the matter to the United Nations. He was not alone. The Indian management saw the repercussions of extending the war: lots of civilian casualties and an absence of resources for the Indian army. According To Sardar Patel’s Correspondence, 1945-50, released in 1974 by the Navjiv
Learn more